The New York Giants' 2025 season was a train wreck waiting to happen, and not just because of their brutal schedule or the devastating injuries that plagued the team early on. But here's where it gets controversial: despite the challenges, the Giants could have avoided becoming the NFL's punching bag for the second year in a row. Instead, they repeatedly shot themselves in the foot with baffling roster decisions that left fans scratching their heads and critics calling for accountability. And this is the part most people miss—these weren’t just minor missteps; they were glaring examples of organizational malpractice that torpedoed any chance of success. Let’s dive into three head-scratching moves that haunted Big Blue last season, and why they matter more than you might think.
1. The Evan Neal and Jalin Hyatt Debacle: Loyalty or Lunacy?
General Manager Joe Schoen has a problem: he holds onto his draft picks like they’re family heirlooms, even when they’re clearly not working out. Take Evan Neal, the seventh overall pick in the 2022 NFL Draft. Touted as a cornerstone of the offensive line, Neal has been a monumental bust. After failing as a pass protector and flopping in a position switch to guard, he spent most of 2025 on the bench or injured reserve, taking up a valuable roster spot without contributing a single snap. Here’s the kicker: Neal’s likely to walk away for nothing, leaving fans wondering why the Giants didn’t cut their losses sooner.
Then there’s Jalin Hyatt, the third-round pick from 2023 who was supposed to be a game-changer at wide receiver. After a decent rookie season, Hyatt’s production plummeted, with just 13 catches over the last two years. Despite his work ethic improving, he never found a role in the offense, even when injuries left the receiver room thin. Is Schoen’s loyalty to these players commendable, or is it a sign of stubbornness? It’s a question worth debating, especially as new head coach John Harbaugh steps in to clean up the mess.
2. The Cor'Dale Flott-Deonte Banks Carousel: A Tale of Misplaced Priorities
The Giants’ cornerback situation in 2025 was a masterclass in how not to manage talent. Deonte Banks, a first-round pick, was clearly a poor fit for defensive coordinator Shane Bowen’s scheme, but the team refused to admit their mistake. Instead, they forced a rotation with Cor'Dale Flott, who had outperformed Banks in training camp. The result? Flott allowed a respectable 71.6 passer rating, while Banks gave up a staggering 149.7. Why did the Giants prioritize draft status over on-field production? It’s a decision that infuriated fans and wasted valuable snaps. While Flott eventually took over full-time, injuries forced Banks back into the lineup, further exposing the team’s mismanagement. With Flott now a pending free agent, Harbaugh will likely overhaul this position entirely—but the damage is already done.
3. Daniel Bellinger’s Untapped Potential: A Missed Opportunity?
Tight end Daniel Bellinger is the kind of player every team needs—reliable, versatile, and underrated. Drafted in the fourth round in 2022, Bellinger has proven himself as both a pass blocker and a capable receiver. Yet, in 2025, he was criminally underutilized, logging just 19 receptions despite his consistent performance. Meanwhile, Theo Johnson, the unquestioned starter, received nearly double the opportunities. Was this a fair distribution of snaps, or did the Giants overlook a hidden gem? Bellinger’s free agency status adds another layer of intrigue. If he thrives elsewhere, it’ll be a stark reminder of the Giants’ recent struggles with talent evaluation.
What’s Next for the Giants?
With John Harbaugh at the helm, the Giants have a chance to turn things around. But the questions remain: Will Schoen learn from his mistakes? Can the team rebuild its roster without repeating past errors? And most importantly, will fans stick around to find out? Let us know your thoughts in the comments—do you agree with these controversial decisions, or do you think the Giants’ front office needs a complete overhaul? One thing’s for sure: the 2025 season was a wake-up call, and the Giants can’t afford to hit snooze again.
For more insights and updates, follow us on Facebook and YouTube. Got a question? Send it our way—we’re here to keep the conversation going!
